Another semester passes by, and another few months older and $10K more in debt. Not really smarter, just older and poorer.
This semester I watched the new library students run around, getting adjusted to their new environment. The general conclusion about this semester’s students is that they don’t have a clue. They have a clue what they want librarianship to be and what library school should be. But, when it comes to reality, they’re pretty much clueless. Now, one could say that the majority of students are clueless when starting out and through time they will know what they need to know. While I do agree with the previous statement for certain things, like what specialization or track one should take, it really doesn’t stand up to when students are clueless of what is actually happening in their chosen field. Like what happens in public libraries everyday. What do you mean I have to deal with homeless people? Screaming children that were left alone in the library? Bodily fluids on various places? It just seems natural to me that if you are going to devote a good part of your life in one setting, you should at least know what’s going on.
One reason for this lack of knowledge is lack of experience. I met many new library students that have no library experience. None. No experience in other positions that might be applicable, like teaching, researcher, etc. Most of these students entered library school straight from the completion of their undergraduate degree, so not only you’re dealing with no related work experience, you’re dealing with very little “school-free”* life experience as well. If you are more inclined to mathematical thinking, the equation of the above situation looks like this:
(No library experience + little “school-free”* life experience) + library school degree = qualified for professional library/information specialist position
To think that one could get a professional position without experience is troublesome. Library school does not have a lot of opportunities for practical application in the field. Practicums and field projects exist, but if a student wants to have more time at field projects beyond the requirement, there is not much room in the program itself. And since most librarians are not of the Type A stock, most will complete the minimum requirements and leave it at that. They’ll complain about the classes on how they aren’t practical, but they won’t do anything more than that.
I mentioned in an earlier entry about the possibility of requiring experience in a library or information environment before entering library school. Students who go in without experience and don’t make the effort to get experience are doing a disservice to themselves and the other students who have to listen to them whine and moan about not being able to get a professional job. Instead they have to take a (Higher Powers forbid) paraprofessional position that is below them since they have a professional degree, etc. etc. etc. These people have no clue that a degree does not automatically get you one of those plentiful jobs out in the booming librarian job market (thank ALA for that one). You have to work for it, and not just showing up at Annual with a resume and a sign that says “hire me”- actually working in the field, paid or not. Who knows- maybe, just maybe, that experience might help you land that professional position.
Enough soapboxing for now. I could go on about how the new students see ALA, but that’s a whole other post.
*I hesitate to say real life at this point because not all college experiences are not the same. Needless to say, after spending time with undergrads for the past year, I would conclude that many could not find their way out of a wet paper bag.